Railroad board is one of the best types of paper to use. It comes in 4-ply (four layers) and 6-ply (six layers). Use the 6-ply railroad board: It is stiffer and it works extremely well. On page 135 of The Paper Boomerang Book: Build Them, Throw Them, and Get Them to Return Every Time, I have listed some sources where you can purchase this paper. If you cannot find a local store that sells this paper, you can purchase it at http://www.paperboomerangs.com/. But to save money, try to find a local source for the paper to avoid the cost of mailing. My book explains how to find this paper, but I will do further research and post additional stores across the United States that carry this paper.
Note: Some office supply stores do not make a distinction between railroad board and poster board, but there is a great difference. Poster board does not work! It is too floppy. Be sure you're getting the 6-ply railroad board. It is stiffer and thicker than poster board. Pacon Creative Products has both the poster board and the railroad board. Be sure to purchase the 6-ply railroad board. They come in 22 in. x 28 in. sheets and in various colors.
Note: Some office supply stores do not make a distinction between railroad board and poster board, but there is a great difference. Poster board does not work! It is too floppy. Be sure you're getting the 6-ply railroad board. It is stiffer and thicker than poster board. Pacon Creative Products has both the poster board and the railroad board. Be sure to purchase the 6-ply railroad board. They come in 22 in. x 28 in. sheets and in various colors.